Sunday, January 19, 2014

Is Grace Enough?

Hands are remarkable things.

Kaaren Anderson wrote very poetically about our hands. And it’s funny to me that in my own hands, I can see those of my Dad’s, even though we have engaged in entirely different kinds of labor.

Grace isn’t just about what our hands do. We do lots of things, lots of acts of kindness, with our hands…we might even do this every day.

Just before dinner at our house, if we are being mindful, we say grace.

Now, we have a couple of them. 

One is short and a little deistic.

(At this point I point to the sky, then I point to an imagined dinner plate. I then smile and made a "thumbs up!" gesture.)

The other is somewhat longer.

Bless the sun and the earth and the marriage in between.
Bless those who till, those who plant, those who water, those to harvest.
Bless those who transport, those who sell and those who prepare this food.
May we take the energy from what we eat and use it to make good in the world.

The whole time we say this grace, I am picturing the hands that my food has passed through.  Even if those hands are really not touching the food, but touching some machinery which is touching my food.  I’m thinking, for example, about the salted peanuts I sometimes eat for a snack. Even if some poor soul isn’t shelling every peanut and roasting it for me, someone is surely not making enough money dealing with the machine that does it faster than a human could.

So for me, the prayer becomes Bless those (hands) who till, those (hands) who plant, the hands that water, the hands that harvest. Bless the hands who transport, the hands that arranged the food nicely in Sprouts, and the one of us in the house who took the raw materials and made them into something yummy.

The Rev. Kate Braestrup, a Unitarian Universalist minister who works as the Chaplain for the State of Maine’s Game Warden Service wrote a book called Beginner’s Grace. In the book, whose intention it is to make things like prayer more accessible, wrote this grace, for those who live busy lives.

May the hungry be well fed. May the well fed hunger for justice. Amen. [1]


Today’s question, Is Grace Enough, was prompted by a discussion between myself and our worship associate for the month, Tina G.

As I talked about last week, grace is a gift. You can see grace as a gift from the Universe, from a Loving God, from another human being. But is that enough?

I think that often it is, but part of the effectiveness of Grace might depend on timing.

With the wrong timing, grace can be confused with irony. Canadian artist, Alanis Morrisette, said it like this “An old man turned 98, he won the lottery and died the next day… isn’t it ironic?”

She goes further, and I’m not going to quote the whole song, but there’s a line in it “It’s like rain on your wedding day.” This year, wouldn’t we love some rain? We have 4 inches of rain last year in total, but on my wedding day?

And finally, “It’s like meeting the man of your dreams, and then meeting his beautiful wife,” an especially frustrating experience for a gay man.

Taken one way, each of these things that Alanis talks of could well be gifts from the universe to you.  But at the wrong time, it’s less than useful.


Often in the discussion about social justice there is, bandied about, the word paternalism. Paternalism is defined as:
the policy or practice on the part of people in positions of authority of restricting the freedom and responsibilities of those subordinate to them in the subordinates' supposed best interest.[2]

The Social Gospel movement of the late 19th and early 20th centuries is often seen as having engaged too much in paternalism as part of its social mission.

Jane Addams did this, at first. As did her life-long friend, Unitarian Emily Greene Balch, who worked in poor neighborhoods in Boston. Both Jane and Emily created “settlement houses” in poor neighborhoods in their cities, and initially, they tried to bring new immigrants more smoothly into our American melting pot by trying to teach them how to let go of their ethnic identities and embrace their new country.

To our modern ears, the idea that Addams and Balch would do such silly things as ask Italians to cook food more plainly because their spicy food made them more emotive and prone to emotionality, to our modern sensibilities this sounds ridiculous, offensive, and high minded.
Please keep in mind that this was all a new discipline and career back then, and it’s from these painful lessons that we, as a culture have evolved. It is because of these mistakes that we now keep a cultural competency with us as we engage the world of social justice.

To the best of our abilities, of course. We have not completely conquered paternalism in our own time, in our own efforts.

Though the many people who engaged in settlement housing efforts were, if could be easily argued, trying to make the world better for the greatly suffering immigrants and, here I am thinking particularly of Rev. Jenkin Lloyd Jones and his settlement house in Chicago focused on helping freed slaves and their descendants, in a way, they were both trying to lay the ground work for grace, and also trying to force grace to happen.

They had a mission of grace, but they were often not willing to just sit and let grace happen. Rather than invite grace, they tried to induce it.

And so often, lessons were lost, opportunities for grace were missed, because the timing and the method weren’t appropriate to the needs of all involved.

I say this not to discount their valiant efforts. As a student of the social gospel movement, I firmly believe that the efforts of our forebears helped bend the arc of the universe toward justice.

A phrase that the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King used, a phrase that he borrowed from our forebear, Rev. Theodore Parker.



Grace, even with the best of intentions, cannot be forced.

It cannot be earned.

Here I told a personal story, without script.


Obviously, while you cannot will a moment of Grace to come to you, nor can you force a moment of grace to come through you, you can however, be ever open to it.

Imagine with me for a moment the Lotus Flower.

A lotus flower grows best in the muckiest, pondiest environments. And yet its flower is renown in several ancient religions as sacred.

My own Buddhist teacher, while teaching us to read, let me correct that, begin to read, the Wonderful Dharma of the Lotus Sutra, Michio Sinuzaki taught us that one of the reasons that the Lotus flower is such a sacred image is not only that it even though it grows in a mucky, muddy, slippery, dirty pond and yet still is able to produce blemish less flower petals, the flower continually produces a seemingly endless supply of these petals.

Which some have taken to symbolize the constant rebirth of the soul as it travels through many lifetimes.

Take then, a lesson from the beautiful lotus.

Be ever open to the possibilities of grace in your life. As you live from day to day, produce the beautiful petals that are your daily life.

Keep the image of the lotus flower with you, and when life is less than kind to you, think of it. Remember that every life goes up and down. I don’t mean to minimize your own, personal struggle, of course. I just wish to normalize it.

There have been events in each of our lives which have been so terrible, that we could scarcely imagine living another day.

There have been moments in life that have been so perfect, that even in the middle of them, we have grieved a little, because we know that moment cannot last forever.

Grace may find you in either place.

You cannot invite grace. You cannot earn grace.

You can only remain open to it.




[1] Braestrup, Kate (2010-11-02). Beginner's Grace: Bringing Prayer to Life (p. 238). Atria Books. Kindle Edition.

[2] Merriam  Webster.

No comments:

Post a Comment